UCI Bans Transgender Women from Female Cycling Competitions
On 14 July 2023, the governing body of world cycling, the Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI), banned transgender women from participating in female cycling competitions. The UCI stated this was necessary to protect the female category and ensure equal opportunities. The UCI President said the organisation has “a duty to guarantee, above all, equal opportunities for all competitors in cycling competitions.”
Legal Context: Caster Semenya and Human Rights
Just a few days prior, the European Court of Human Rights ruled in favour of Caster Semenya, a differences of sexual development (DSD) athlete previously prohibited from international competition by World Athletics.
The Court found that preventing Semenya from competing without hormone therapy violated:
- Article 14: prohibition of discrimination combined with
- Article 8: right to respect for private life
- Article 13: right to an effective remedy in relation to Articles 14 and 8
This shows the UCI’s decision transcends sport and could potentially face challenges in human rights courts globally.
Public Reaction
After the announcement, social media exploded with support for the decision, citing the integrity and fairness of women’s sport. However, some questioned why this advocacy was absent in previous fights for equality.
Personal Experience in Women’s Cycling Advocacy
In 2012, I received a suspended fine for publicly criticising the then head of the UCI for stating women’s cycling wasn’t developed enough to warrant a minimum wage. One of the men who criticised me then, Joe Papp, is now a vocal advocate for protecting women’s competitions.
Equality in Women’s Cycling
While the UCI claims to ensure equal opportunities, reality is still unequal:
- Women’s minimum WorldTour salary is €13,026 less than men’s
- Race exposure, opportunities, and prize money remain unequal
Call to Action: Support Women’s Sport
If you want to genuinely champion women’s sport, focus on:
- Equal pay and opportunity
- Safe workplaces for women with transparent misconduct reporting
- Challenging outdated norms instead of labelling women negatively for speaking out
Transparency and Governance
I contacted the UCI about the composition of the management committee that decided the ban. One of the two recognised female cycling unions was not consulted, as noted by The Cyclist’s Alliance. Decisions for women must be made with women, not just for them.
Final Thoughts
The UCI transgender ban highlights ongoing debates about fairness, athlete protection, and equal opportunity in sport. Advocacy, consistent policy, and transparency are essential to ensure women’s sport continues to progress.
Read more stories from Hosking Bikes